Fitch Lodge
Bohemian, low-key, neighborhood-y. Think tropical porch energy rather than resort gloss. Staff are genuinely chatty and helpful, not scripted.
Book direct at keywesthistoricinns.com for the best rates — they regularly offer 20–30% off with extra perks not available on OTAs.
Why It Matters
One of the few Key West hotels where the architecture itself is the attraction. The Carpenter Victorian exteriors are virtually unchanged from the turn of the 20th century. Listed on the National Registry of Historic Places.
Four 19th-century Carpenter Victorian conch houses converted into a 44-room inn in the heart of Old Town Key West. Named for Henry 'Harry' Fitch — a Coast Guard seaman, carpenter, and postmaster — the property is listed on the National Registry of Historic Places. It looks more like a residential block than a hotel, and that's precisely the point.
Where You'll Stay
5 room types available
King
More breathing room than the Single Queen, centered around a plush king bed. Size ranges 200–240 sq ft depending on the unit. Good pick for couples who want the extra bed space.
1 King
King or Queen Mobility Accessible
Accessible features for guests with mobility needs. Can be booked directly through the property website. Same bohemian-tropical decor as standard rooms.
1 King or QueenSingle Queen
Compact and efficient. A queen bed, the essentials, and a vibe that says 'you're here to explore, not lounge.' Rooms are tight by modern standards but well-kept and decorated with bohemian tropical accents.
1 QueenTwo Bedroom Suite
The largest option and the only one that actually feels like you have room to breathe. Two separate king bedrooms, a sofa bed, a full kitchen, and its own living area — legitimately good for families or two couples splitting costs.
2 Kings + 1 Sofa BedTwo Queens
The go-to for small families or two friends traveling together. Ranges 245–420 sq ft, so size varies by unit. Light and breezy island atmosphere with bohemian touches.
2 QueensThe Property
Eat & Drink
2 venues on property
Restaurant
Spa & Wellness
Treatment Menu
On Property
How you'll actually spend your days.
Partnership with Island Safari Rentals. Cruiser bikes, e-bikes, scooters, and golf carts available. Book via QR code on bike signage around the property or through the front desk.
The on-property concierge (Jenny Berube) can arrange charter boats, booze cruises, sunset sails, scuba diving, kayaking, eco-tours, and even quick flights or boat trips to the Dry Tortugas.
A beautiful outdoor pool with lounge chairs and a dedicated sundeck. Open 7 AM–10 PM daily. The pool area is a quiet, serene spot — good for winding down after a full day.
Exclusive guest discounts on snorkel and dive trips plus gear rentals through SouthPoint Divers at 606 Front Street. Concierge can arrange bookings.
Yoga mats available in every room. No structured classes on-site.
Amenities & Practical Info
The details that matter for planning.
Two-story property with no elevator. Accessible rooms available on ground floor.
Available from 7 AM to 6 PM daily.
Complimentary daily breakfast from 8–10 AM. Danish, pastries, juices, coffee, fruit, cereal, oatmeal, yogurt.
Complimentary access to digital newspapers and books via PressReader app.
No on-site parking. Street parking and city lots available nearby.
No size or breed restrictions on dogs. Each dog gets a complimentary 'Pup Cup' on arrival. $50/night pet fee applies.
No smoking or vaping anywhere on the property.
Open 7 AM–10 PM. Sun loungers and a sundeck included.
Available on departure day so guests can explore before heading out.
Personalized concierge (Jenny Berube) available for trip planning, local tips, and activity bookings. Included in resort fee.
BUILD YOUR FITCH LODGE - KEY WEST HISTORIC INNS PLAN
Rooms, dining, spa, and resort experiences — organized into one trip plan.
Start Planning