
The Menhaden
Coastal-nautical minimalism. Monochrome interiors with driftwood accents and maritime artifacts — bricks, bottles, and a whaling ship mast discovered during construction. Sharp and modern, but with genuine local character rather than manufactured beach aesthetic.
Book the Studio King / ADA for water views of Greenport Harbor — not all rooms overlook the harbor
Why It Matters
Michelin Key recipient and the only boutique hotel on the North Fork with a rooftop bar overlooking Greenport Harbor and Shelter Island. The location — two blocks from the LIRR terminal and steps from the Shelter Island Ferry — is unbeatable for car-free NYC visitors.
The Menhaden is a 16-room boutique hotel sitting right on Front Street in Greenport — the former fishing village that's now the heart of Long Island wine country. Michelin Key recognized, it trades in a sharp monochrome palette of white, black, and neutrals, with Restoration Hardware furnishings, Apotheke toiletries, and bathrooms that manage to feel genuinely luxurious in a building this size. The rooftop bar is the North Fork's only hotel rooftop, and the per-floor galleys stocked with complimentary snacks, Häagen-Dazs, and fresh pastries make the $40 amenity fee feel like a deal.
Where You'll Stay
6 room types available
The Property
Eat & Drink
3 venues on property
Restaurant
Spa & Wellness
Treatment Menu
On Property
How you'll actually spend your days.
Complimentary beach gear for guests including beach chairs, coolers, beach bags, umbrellas, and towels (first come, first serve). Beach vehicle passes also available. The concierge can arrange dog-friendly beach recommendations and beach picnics.
The concierge packs a picnic of local cheeses, snacks, and an optional bottle of local wine for a trip to 67 Steps Beach. Requires 48 hours advance notice.
Paint a smooth chocolate canvas using vibrant cocoa butter paints guided by expert chocolatiers at Disset Chocolate. 4-person minimum. Contact for pricing.
A dock-based tour on an oyster boat covering the operations of a small oyster farm on the Peconic Bay, including a shucking lesson. Approximately one hour; includes oysters and a souvenir.
A fleet of loaner bikes available to all guests at no charge. Ride the village streets, head to 67 Steps Beach, or ask the concierge to curate a custom bike route through the North Fork backroads.
The hotel's custom electric Moke car is complimentary for guests and available on request through the front desk. Used for beach runs, sunset picnics, and bespoke concierge experiences.
A private chauffeured tour of three handpicked North Fork wineries with a custom itinerary based on your preferences. Contact the front desk for pricing and availability.
An exclusive add-on for Menhaden guests: a private educational tour of Macari Vineyards' vineyard and cellar in Mattituck led by a WSET-certified Wine Educator, followed by a guided tasting of five premium wines paired with cheese, charcuterie, and gourmet sandwiches in the barrel cellar. Weekdays 11am–3pm, weekends 11am–12pm.
A Saturday afternoon hands-on session at Matchbook Distilling's Apothecary. Learn to nose and taste spirits, dive into the science of distilling, and blend your own 750ml bottle of signature gin to take home.
Craft a custom red blend using estate-grown Petit Verdot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, and Merlot at RGNY Winery, guided by a wine expert. Approximately 90 minutes. Includes artisanal snacks and a custom bottle of your blend.
Saturday afternoon whisky tasting where guests sample spirits drawn from full barrels using a thief, learning about proofing and distilling. Limited spots per session.
Hands-on art workshops including hand-building pottery and abstract art sessions with VEME Studios. Private and group classes available. Contact for pricing.
A 6-person private cruise aboard a restored 1936 Chris Craft Yacht exploring the Peconic Bay, Shelter Island, Sunset Beach, or the owner's local oyster farm. Includes complimentary oysters and a bottle of local sparkling wine.
Sunset sailing experiences arranged through East End Charters or Layla Sailing. Contact the concierge for availability and pricing.
A luxe s'mores kit with sea-salt chocolate and handmade marshmallows, served around the rooftop firepits with harbor views. Weather permitting.
A private oyster shucking class on the rooftop while sipping rosé. Minimum 6 people. Includes local oysters, shucking lesson, and education on what makes North Fork oysters distinct.
A private yoga session on the rooftop deck with a local instructor. Available for groups of six or more adults at a date and time of your choosing. Contact the front desk to arrange.
Amenities & Practical Info
The details that matter for planning.
ADA-accessible rooms with accessible entry, ADA bathrooms, closed-caption TVs. Accessible lobby, restaurant, and common areas. Service animals welcome.
Complimentary beach chairs, coolers, beach bags, umbrellas, beach towels, and vehicle beach passes available for guests. First come, first serve.
Flexible meeting space accommodating up to 45 people. Available for corporate retreats, private events, and group gatherings. Full-property buyouts available for weddings and larger events.
Complimentary high-speed Wi-Fi throughout the hotel. Included in the amenity fee.
On-site elevator providing access to all floors.
North Fork's only hotel rooftop bar, perched at the highest point in Greenport. Views of Greenport Harbor, Shelter Island, and the North Ferry. Fire pits, lounge seating, and a full bar. Guests only.
Each floor has a guest galley stocked with complimentary snacks and beverages. Morning pastries, afternoon curated snacks, and a special evening treat. Häagen-Dazs in the freezer. Included in the $40/night amenity fee.
Ground-floor grab-and-go café with For Five coffee, croissants, pastries, and gourmet provisions. Perfect for morning coffee or picnic supplies.
Complimentary on-site parking available on a first-come, first-serve basis. Included in the $40/night amenity fee. Overflow parking is nearby.
Select pet-friendly rooms accommodate one dog under 25 lbs. Non-refundable $75 pet fee. Must be booked by calling the front desk directly.
On-site gift shop and General Store with local provisions and hotel merchandise.
Hotel gift cards available for purchase online.
Daily housekeeping provided. Guests can opt out if preferred.
24-hour front desk and security. Guest contact via text service also available.
Full concierge service available via phone and text. Can arrange wine tours, restaurant reservations, sailing excursions, beach picnics, in-room spa services, photography sessions, and more.
Custom electric Moke car available to guests (first-come basis, contact the front desk). Used for beach runs and bespoke concierge excursions. Complimentary.
A fleet of loaner bikes available to all guests for exploring Greenport Village, the beach, and backroads. Included in the amenity fee.
BUILD YOUR THE MENHADEN PLAN
Rooms, dining, spa, and resort experiences — organized into one trip plan.
Start Planning

